1.3 Tipping points in the biosphere

David I. Armstrong McKay, Boris Sakschewski, Rosa M. Roman-Cuesta*, Vasilis Dakos, Bernardo M. Flores, Dag O. Hessen, Marina Hirota, Sonia Kéfi, David Obura, Christopher P.O. Reyer, Carla Staver, Dominik Thom, Beniamino Abis, Cibele Amaral, Tom Andersen, Sebastian Bathiany, Gregory Beaugrand, Thorsten Blenckner, Victor Brovkin, Miguel Berdugo, Manuel Delgado-Baquerizo, Kyle G. Dexter, Markus Drüke, Norman C. Duke, Daniel Friess, Jorge A. Herrera Silveira, Alina Bill-Weilandt, Emilio Guirado, Milena Holmgren, Sarian Kosten, Catherine Lovelock, Angeles G. Mayor, Daniel J. Mayor, Melanie McField, Mariana Meerhoff, Israel Muñiz Castillo, Susa Niiranen, Steve Paton, Paul Pearce-Kelly, Yolanda Pueyo Estaún, Juan Rocha, Giovanni Romagnoni, Jose A. Sanabria-Fernandez, Camilla Sguotti, Bryan M. Spears, Arie Staal, Nicola Stevens, Geraint A. Tarling, Andy Wiltshire

*We thank the generous support of the BNP-PARIBAS Foundation on their 2019 Climate and Biodiversity Initiative call, and the funding of the CORESCAM project (“Coastal Biodiversity Resilience to Increasing Extreme Events in Central America”)

Key Messages

  • Evidence exists for tipping points in a variety of ecosystems, including forest dieback, tree and bush encroachment in savanna and grasslands, dryland desertification, lake eutrophication, coral reef die-off and fishery collapse.
  • Several biomes (such as mangroves and the Amazon rainforest) are losing resilience and approaching key tipping thresholds, with current warming levels already triggering coral reef die-off tipping points in multiple regions.
  • Ecosystem tipping points can be driven by many different drivers (including, but not limited to, climate change) that interact in complex ways across many species and feedbacks, making it harder to assess whether tipping points may be imminent.

Recommendations

  • Reduce pressure on global ecosystems through the urgent phase-out of greenhouse gas emissions as well as tackling exploitation, habitat loss and pollution.
  • Promote ecological resilience through adaptive management, ecosystem restoration and inclusive conservation, supporting sustainable livelihoods and rights for Indigenous peoples and local communities, and improved governance of land and oceans.
  • Address deep uncertainties around feedbacks controlling ecosystem tipping and the impacts of increasingly extreme events, plant adaptability and spatial variability through more and better-integrated observations, experiments, and improved models.
  • Invest in observations (field and remote sensing) and experiments to monitor and detect declining ecosystem resilience and potential early warning signals. 
  • Foster greater data sharing and international collaboration, and co-design research to bring together researchers across natural and social sciences and Global North and South, as well as Indigenous and traditional ecological knowledge.

Summary

This chapter assesses scientific evidence for tipping points across the biosphere, which comprises Earth’s ecosystems. Human-driven habitat loss, pollution, exploitation and, increasingly, climate change are degrading ecosystems across the planet, some of which can pass tipping points beyond which a ‘regime shift’ to an alternative (and often less diverse or beneficial) ecosystem state occurs. 

Evidence for tipping points emerges across many biomes. In forests, large parts of the Amazon rainforest could tip to degraded forest or impoverished savanna, while tipping in boreal forests is possible but more uncertain, and whether current temperate forest disturbance could lead to tipping is unclear. In open savannas and drylands, drying could lead to desertification in some areas, while in others encroachment by trees and shrubs could see these biodiverse ecosystems shift to a forested or degraded state. Nutrient pollution and warming can trigger lakes to switch to an algae-dominated low-oxygen state. Coral reefs are already experiencing tipping points, as more frequent warming-driven bleaching events, along with pollution, extreme weather events and diseases, tip them to degraded algae-dominated states. Mangroves and seagrasses are at risk of regional tipping, along with kelp forests, marine food webs and some fisheries, which are known to be able to collapse. 

Together, these tipping points threaten the livelihoods of millions of people, and some thresholds are likely imminent. Stabilising climate is critical for reducing the likelihood of widespread ecosystem tipping points, but tackling other pressures can also help increase ecological resilience, push back tipping and support human wellbeing.

Bezos Earth Fund University of Exeter logo
Earth Commission Systems Change Lab logo Systemiq logo
Global Tipping Points logo
Share this content
Top