2.2 Assessing Impacts of Earth System Tipping Points on Human Societies

Richard Betts, James G. Dyke, Elizabeth Fuller, Laura Jackson, Laurie Laybourn, Norman J. Steinert, Yangyang Xu

Key Messages

  • Earth system tipping points have the potential for severe impacts on people and biodiversity.
  • Amazon dieback, ice sheet collapse, permafrost thawing and AMOC collapse are the most-studied tipping points for impacts, each having the potential for impacts on water, food and energy security, health, ecosystem services, communities and economies.
  • Amazon dieback could put 6 million people at risk of extreme heat stress and cause US$1-3.5 trillion economic damages.
  • Antarctic ice sheet instability leading to a potential sea level rise of 2 metres by 2100 would expose 480 million people to annual coastal flooding events.
  • Permafrost thawing already damages property and infrastructure; 70% of current infrastructure in permafrost regions is in areas with high potential for thaw by 2050.
  • An AMOC collapse would disrupt regional climates worldwide, substantially reducing vegetation and crop productivity across large areas of the world, with profound implications for food security.

Recommendations

  • Improved assessments of the impacts of Earth system tipping points are urgently needed.
  • Existing international, national and local risk assessments and adaptation plans should give deeper consideration to the implications of Earth system tipping points through the systematic use of available Earth system models, impact models and storylines of tipping point scenarios.
  • Risk assessments should include the implications of tipping points for both the likelihood of more severe impacts and the uncertainties in possible outcomes, with consequent challenges for effective adaptation planning.
  • Improved interdisciplinary collaboration between natural and social scientists is needed to ensure adequate representation of risk when assessing the economic impacts of crossing Earth system tipping points.
  • Assessments should go beyond economic damages to broader human, social and cultural impacts of crossing Earth system tipping points, starting with food and water security; effects on infrastructure, housing and ‘loss of place’; health and liveability; movement of people, capital and material; cognitive and emotional impacts; cultural and identity changes; and international relations, etc.

Summary

Assessments of climate change effects on humans and ecosystems have previously included only limited information on the consequences of climate tipping points. While some national evaluations have touched on tipping point implications, assessment has been largely qualitative, with minimal quantitative analysis. Understanding and quantification of impacts of tipping points is recognised as a significant knowledge gap, and improving the research base in this area is essential for climate risks to be fully evaluated. 

This chapter examines the current knowledge of Earth system tipping point impacts on people, exploring the evidence on impacts from individual tipping points, and assessing specific sectors and their vulnerability to these tipping points. Localised effects arise when climate tipping points, such as permafrost thaw and forest dieback, are crossed. These effects stem from land surface changes and alterations in regional climates and weather extremes. Global impacts manifest through large-scale shifts in atmospheric and oceanic circulations, altering global warming rates and sea level rise. Oceanic dynamics, like collapse of the AMOC, can reshape regional climates and cause widespread shifts in temperature and precipitation patterns. Similarly, cryospheric tipping points, such as marine ice cliff collapse, have the potential to accelerate sea level rise, affecting flooding hazards like coastal inundation. Biosphere tipping points, such as Amazon dieback, intensify greenhouse gas concentrations, hastening global warming and its associated extreme weather events, regional climate shifts and sea level rise. 

All these have the potential to impact the security of water, food and energy, human health, ecosystem services, communities and economies. The body of evidence varies across tipping points and sectors, but the implications for profound impacts across all areas of human society are clear.

Bezos Earth Fund University of Exeter logo
Earth Commission Systems Change Lab logo Systemiq logo
Global Tipping Points logo
Share this content
Top